Homegrown Magic
Wednesday, May 28th, 2008
Jeanmarie Says: So Eric Khoo’s My Magic didn’t win the big Palme d’Or prize at the recently-concluded Cannes Film Festival.
But did we really expect it to? I don’t mean to belittle our local film industry, but in this case, to be able to be nominated in the main competition and walk the red carpet of an international event is already a national victory and career-high achievement.
And, slowly but surely, a stepping stone to greater things. Best Foreign Film at the Oscars in 10 years time, perhaps? We can dream a little, right?
So what, if, in typically Singaporean fashion, we require endorsement from outsiders in order to embrace and support our homegrown products? Admit it. With all the positive feedback and media attention My Magic has been receiving in the past month and even a reported 15-minute standing ovation at Cannes, isn’t your curiosity piqued? I know I’ll certainly want to catch it when it opens in cinemas here later this year.
But to paraphrase George Orwell, some local films (and directors) are more equal than others. Our movie industry is still in its infancy, and only brand names will sell tickets. Eric has always been a festival darling, especially when Be With Me opened the Directors’ Fortnight at Cannes in 2005.
His protege Royston Tan seems to have the most potential to achieve similar success, even though his crowd-pleasing getai flick 881 didn’t resonate critically, in terms of scoring awards or nominations at regional events. Could his second getai offering 12 Lotus do the trick?
Meanwhile, Kelvin Tong has gone from arthouse to commercial (The Maid, Men In White, Rule #1), while Jack Neo continues flogging the heartland horse with Money No Enough 2.
So where does that leave Kallang Roar by little-known director Cheng Ding An? Sadly, I predict it will come just as fast and it will go. And noiselessly, too.
Tell Us: Do you think a local film can top Eric Khoo’s feat at Cannes in the future? What do you want to see more of - or less - in the type of movies our Singaporean filmmakers are producing? Which local movie are you most looking forward to watching this year?
You can leave a comment here or e-mail us at tnpshow@sph.com.sg. Don’t forget to leave us your contact details: name, age, occupation and e-mail address or telephone number.
===============================
LETTERS VIA E-MAIL
Is it any surprise that Eric Khoo’s new film didn’t pick up the Palme d’Or? While I was heavily rooting for it, it’s clear that most award selections are very political. It will be difficult for a film out of a small country like Singapore to win. Nonetheless, it’s an achievement being in the running for something as prestigious as the Palme d’Or.
Most of the previous Eric Khoo efforts easier rank among the top twenty films I’ve watched, and I doubt anyone at the moment is capable of supassing his achievements. Remember, Be With Me, could have been in the running for Best Foreign Picture at the Oscars a few years ago, it whatever minimal dialogue wasn’t in English but some other language we’re expected to speak. What’s to say that My Magic, mostly in Tamil, won’t be nominated next year?
While I have watched and enjoyed some films from Singapore, I have also struggled through numerous ones. While the trend in the late 90s was slapstick appealing to the lowest common denominator (all thanks to Money No Enough), the trend these days veer to the extremely pretentious static shots with not much else only Tsai Ming Liang can get away with. There is a catch 22 situation here really. What direction do we take? Will we see future films taking the Jack Neo direction of heartland slapstick and then watch it fall apart like Hong Kong, or Eric Khoo’s arthouse direction that might, hopefully, rank our country as critic darlings when it comes to films much like Iran and parts of the Middle East?
Personally I think art should triumph over commercialism. The best films I’ve seen come from places like Iran, Turkey, Poland which do not have much of a film industry to talk about, but these are the films that are etched in one’s mind longer than the latest heavily promoted blockbuster can ever hope to achieve.
Keith Tan


