April 10th, 2008 Posted in Raven Hanson, Lifestyle | 7 Comments »

Raven Says: So, they have a fat girl in the Miss England competition. Chloe Marshall has become the first “plus-sized” girl to make it to the finals of the UK’s national beauty contest.
I know that calling her a ‘fat girl’ makes me sound anti-curves but that’s just too bad. It’s what she is, with a BMI six points over her 5’10” optimal at the young age of 17. Don’t get me wrong, it’s fine to be full figured and curvaceous; we totally adore fatties Crystal Renn, Nigella Lawson and Sophie Dahl - I’m a happy size 12 myself, but I am quite aware that society seems to be embracing fatness with arms a little too widely open.
It’s worrying that people are accepting being a bigger size when they are NOT NATURALLY THAT SIZE… if you eat more vegetables than anything else, eat only as much as you need and get out of breath exercising three times a week and you are still a size 12 then congratulations, that’s your natural size. If you are sitting on your lazy ass, placing your job before your health and eating deep fried food all over the place, then you’re just a disgusting lazy fat ass who doesn’t deserve the right to complain about your size.
We need to remember that while no size is ‘bad’ or ‘good’, it is wrong to lie to ourselves about our true size and it is right to treat our bodies as they deserve to be treated, no matter what size.
Tell Us: Is big necessarily beautiful?
You can leave a comment here or e-mail us at tnpshow@sph.com.sg . Don’t forget to leave us your contact details: name, age, occupation and e-mail address or telephone number.
===============================
LETTERS VIA E-MAIL
This question made me have two thoughts, beautiful or not beautiful. To me, as a guy, I would not want to criticise the girls who are big in size as that might affect their conscience. However,I would not mind Chloe Marshall winning this competition because I believe she won it with her excellent personality and a little on appearance because she is one of the beautiful big-sized ladies. As said by many, never judge a book by its cover. She may be fat, but she may have done several good deeds behind our backs.
Being fat is not really a healthy sign. According to the health bulletins, obesity tend to result in health problems such as high blood pressure and Arthritis. I hope that these girls will control their daily meal intakes to have a balanced diet.
Therefore, this makes me difficult to tell whether being fat is beautiful or not, but I can surely tell whether it is healthy or not. So, just let everything be natural.
Joel Ong
Big is beautiful if only you feel confident about it yourself, and that usually only goes to people who are naturally born big.
If binging and lazy is the reason that makes you big, people will find you unacceptable.
I know this better than anyone because i used to be big size girl.
Being big size not only makes me out casted by friends, but also crushed my dreams.
So, 7 months ago i took the first step to losing weight and say bye-bye to the 60 KG big girl.
Now i am a 45kg girl, and i get better treatments where ever i go.
After all, this is a realistic world.
Wendy Chong
The thing is, regardless of whether you are overweight because you binge, or you are lazy, or you have a genetic or medical problem or you are naturally towards the larger side, the society at large will still find you unacceptable. Sadly, thinness is the norm in Singapore and anyone who deviates from this norm is termed unacceptable.
How many times have overweight people been stopped in the streets by complete strangers who rudely shove pamphlets of get-thin-quick schemes and slimming products regardless of the place you are at and company you are with?
I don’t believe these ‘ambassadors’ of thinness are doing people like me a favour, I think they are ultimately insensitive and must be given at least a crash course in proper social etiquette. Somehow the general attitude towards big people in Singapore is that 1) they are slobs, 2) they are not active, 3) they eat a lot, 4) they are unattractive and 5) they most probably are not successful.
This myopic view of overweight people is indeed immature as it shows how narrow-minded people really are. I don’t think I have to list the thousands of individuals you and I may know who are overweight AND successful in their lives! We talk about equal human rights and egalitarian beliefs in Singapore but I strongly believe that such rights do not belong to people who are simply overweight in this country.
Forget the fact that the overweight person could be an educated, eloquent or talented person by all means, that does not really matter because the person’s BMI is not within the healthy range. Yes we agree we are unhealthy by all means.
Perhaps we are even burdening the health system in Singapore by being a breeding ground to numerous chronic or acute illnesses that could affect us due to our weight. But it seems as if the addicted smoker gets a more glamourized treatment than an overweight person who may not have any habits like smoking or drinking! At least they don’t have numerous pamphlets shoved at their faces or taxi-drivers and market uncles telling them how to stop smoking effectively. Overweight people are discriminated and there exists a stereotypical view of big people and no one can possibly deny that. The government encourages Singapore to be a gracious society, especially since the country is gaining popularity amongst the foreign crowd.
Perhaps, Singaporeans can start with being gracious to people who are simply different in size than the average person you bump into. Yes appearances influence first impressions, but if the entire world were to operate only on first impressions, we most probably would not have gotten this far. Learn to be sensitive to another person’s feelings, for being overweight is NOT a crime. Sensitivity ought to be the first signs of a civilized society, but are we even close to achieving that?
And yes, big can be beautiful, and no, it is not a way to justify being overweight.
Renuga d/o Konasegaran